I find it difficult to understand why there is so much controversy and outrage over the decision to run a ferry to the Isle of Lewis on a Sunday.
Religious leaders are claiming it is against the fourth commandment "remember the Sabbath day and keep it holy".
I ask this of those who oppose it on religious grounds:
- If your house is on fire on a Sunday would you expect the Fire Brigade to turn up?
- If you are ill on a Sunday would you expect a doctor to treat you?
- Do you listen to the radio or watch TV on a Sunday?
- Do you use electricity on a Sunday?
If you answer yes to these questions you are guilty of double standards, as the commandment does not discriminate against different types of work. And if some people should be allowed to work then it is hypocritical to condemn others.
2 comments:
But they might accuse us of the same double standards, seeing as they hold their god's law above national laws. I think, in general, communities should have the right to decided what is appropriate for their community. I gather, actually, that the majority in the community support the ferries, but are opposed to Sunday trading.
As it's an important part of their culture, if they want it that way, they should have it that way. It may seem ludicrous to us (I don't know, never visited). But I'd be careful about further homogenising western culture, and also the need to recognise minority rights.
My point is that the fourth commandment is only partially followed. There are plenty of people who will work to provide essential services who are not condemned.
Post a Comment